← back to writing

Prompt Improver: Structured Thinking for Better AI Prompts

• 6 min read

After spending countless hours watching developers struggle with AI prompts, one pattern became painfully clear: we're getting better AI models almost monthly...

After spending countless hours watching developers struggle with AI prompts, one pattern became painfully clear: we're getting better AI models almost monthly, but our ability to effectively communicate with them remains surprisingly primitive. Ask ten engineers to write a prompt for the same task, and you'll get ten wildly different approaches with equally variable results.

This isn't just an academic observation. It's a practical problem costing teams real time and money as they blindly grope their way toward workable solutions.

The Root Problem With Prompt Engineering Today

Let's be honest about the current state of prompt engineering. It's not engineering at all—it's mostly trial and error, superstition, and copy-pasting examples from Twitter or Reddit. We've all been there: tweaking words, adding boilerplate phrases we've heard work well, and crossing our fingers.

When I started building Prompt Improver, I wasn't looking to create another AI tool in an already crowded marketplace. I was solving my own frustration: why do we have sophisticated frameworks for every other type of engineering, but prompt creation remains this mysterious art form?

The answer became increasingly apparent: effective prompts aren't just clear instructions—they're structured frameworks that guide AI through complex reasoning processes. They need the right balance of explicit direction and implicit context, of step-by-step guidance and adaptive flexibility.

Yet every tool I found approached this as a surface-level problem. They'd help with grammar or suggest synonyms, but none addressed the fundamental structure of how humans effectively communicate complex instructions to machines.

What Makes Prompt Improver Different

I built Prompt Improver around three core principles that directly address the shortcomings I kept encountering in my own work and in watching other engineers:

1. Structure Without Killing Creativity

Most template-based tools force you into rigid formats that might work for basic tasks but fall apart for anything nuanced. It's like having a form to fill out rather than a conversation.

Prompt Improver takes the opposite approach. It enhances your existing prompts through structural principles while preserving what makes them uniquely yours. The structure serves your intent, not the other way around.

I've sat with teams who abandoned other prompt tools because they felt constrained. One developer put it perfectly: "I don't need another tool telling me exactly what words to use. I need something that helps me think more clearly about what I'm trying to get the AI to do."

2. Context-Aware Enhancement

The most dangerous type of prompt tool is one that makes superficial improvements while missing the underlying purpose. I've watched teams waste days optimizing prompts that were fundamentally solving the wrong problem.

Prompt Improver focuses on contextual understanding first. It doesn't just make your prompt prettier—it makes sure your prompt actually addresses what you're trying to accomplish. This means identifying missing constraints, clarifying ambiguous instructions, and highlighting potential misalignments between your stated goal and your prompt structure.

The difference is subtle but crucial. One early user explained: "For the first time, I can see that what I thought was a prompt failure was actually a thinking failure. I wasn't asking for what I really wanted."

3. Learning While Building

The dirty secret about most prompt tools: they create dependency rather than mastery. You become reliant on the tool rather than developing your own expertise.

This pattern drives me crazy. Prompt Improver deliberately inverts this relationship by exposing the thinking behind improvements. Every enhancement comes with clear explanations of why certain structures work better than others, so you're not just getting better prompts—you're becoming better at creating prompts yourself.

This philosophy manifests in several practical ways:

  • Explanations that connect specific improvements to general principles
  • Examples showing how and why enhanced prompts perform differently
  • Suggestions for iteration based on your specific goals
  • Just-in-time learning resources that appear when relevant

The Technical Reality

Since most readers of this blog are fellow developers, you're probably wondering about implementation details. Prompt Improver isn't built on magic—it's built on React, TypeScript, and Tailwind CSS. I chose these technologies specifically because they enable the kind of adaptable, responsive experience that prompt improvement requires.

(And yes, I'm aware of the irony that this tech stack sounds suspiciously AI-influenced—thanks, Cursor, for the not-so-subtle nudge toward modern web development!)

The component-based architecture allows for the modular enhancement of different prompt elements, while TypeScript provides the type safety needed for reliable transformations. Tailwind and the shadcn-ui component library give us consistent interaction patterns without sacrificing customization.

But technology choices matter less than the fundamental approach. The system needs to be robust enough to provide reliable improvements while adapting to wildly different user needs and contexts.

Why Most Prompt Engineering Tools Fail

I've watched numerous prompt engineering tools launch to initial excitement only to be abandoned weeks later. The pattern is almost always the same: they focus on improving prompts as isolated artifacts rather than as expressions of human thinking.

This fundamental misalignment leads to tools that:

  • Offer superficial improvements that don't meaningfully impact results
  • Create dependency rather than developing user capability
  • Optimize for generic "best practices" rather than specific contexts
  • Ignore the learning journey of becoming better at prompt engineering

Prompt Improver deliberately avoids these traps by focusing on the thinking process behind prompt creation. It's not just about getting better prompts today—it's about becoming better at prompt engineering tomorrow.

The Ultimate Test: Does It Actually Help?

After hours of development and testing with real users (read: people who would put up with me pestering them endlessly), I've come to measure Prompt Improver's success by a simple metric: are users getting consistently better results from their AI interactions?

The early signs are encouraging. Users report not just better immediate outcomes, but a deeper understanding of how to structure their prompts effectively. As one tester put it: "I'm thinking differently about how I communicate with AI now. It's not just about being clearer—it's about structuring my thinking in ways the AI can process more effectively."

That's the core promise of Prompt Improver: not just another tool that edits your prompts, but a platform that changes how you think about prompt engineering itself.

Where We Go From Here

Prompt engineering is still in its infancy. As models grow more sophisticated, our ability to communicate effectively with them will become increasingly valuable. Prompt Improver is my contribution to this emerging discipline—a practical tool built by a developer who got tired of watching smart people waste time on trial-and-error approaches to what should be a systematic process.

If you're interested in trying it out or providing feedback, visit pi.haasonsaas.com. I'm constantly refining the platform based on real user experiences, and I'd genuinely value your perspective.

Effective prompt engineering shouldn't be a mysterious art form accessible only to those with endless time for experimentation. It should be a structured discipline with clear principles and reproducible results. That's the future I'm working toward with Prompt Improver, and I hope you'll join me on that journey.

Acknowledgements

This vision comes to life through my personal dedication to creating something I needed but couldn't find in the market.

Special thanks to my early users whose thoughtful feedback continues to shape Prompt Improver's evolution, and to the broader AI community whose work inspires my own. The journey toward truly effective prompt engineering tools is just beginning, and I'm honored to be part of it.

share

next up